Who Goes Nazi? (1941)So I went to see not a little political leader, but a probable dictator “as certain to come to power as that I stand here,” he had told some newspaper men a few days before. A man who owns an army. A man who terrorizes the streets. A man who predicts the constitution of a new dangerous, and awakened Germany.[...] She was "the most influential woman" in the United States, after Eleanor Roosevelt -- "and it may be said of Miss Thompson," said Time, "that she came up over a rockier path." Her thrice-weekly column, "On the Record," originating in The New York Herald Tribune, was syndicated to more than 200 papers in America; she was heard nightly on the radio by tens of millions of people; and during just one week, in 1937, she was obliged to turn down 700 invitations to speak to them in the flesh -- at rallies, conventions, clubs, forums, dinners, commencements, business "roasts" and so on. "With a clang like a powerfully swung hammer, she beat upon general confusion of mind till the will to defend democracy was forged."Dorothy Thompson was a towering figure in American journalism and, thanks to the influence that gave her, in world affairs. That assessment of Hitler got her kicked out of Nazi Germany two years later but did not slow her activism against the regime and, on behalf of Jewish refugees. Her great gift, as Jack Alexander says in the quote above, was to take cosmic injustices personally and make her readers feel them too. Happily, she has experienced something of a revival in recent years both because of her role in an American Experience on the Nazi American Bund and because of this essay, in which so many can see parallels to identifying Trumpists. The whole is worth reading, but here's an extensive quote: The saturnine man over there talking with a lovely French emigree is already a Nazi. Mr. C is a brilliant and embittered intellectual. He was a poor white-trash Southern boy, a scholarship student at two universities where he took all the scholastic honors but was never invited to join a fraternity. His brilliant gifts won for him successively government positions, partnership in a prominent law firm, and eventually a highly paid job as a Wall Street adviser. He has always moved among important people and always been socially on the periphery. His colleagues have admired his brains and exploited them, but they have seldom invited him—or his wife—to dinner.It is the insecurities of such people we so readily recognize (see also Eric Hoffer's True Believer. And the great irony here is that while such Identitarians insist on the uniqueness of their cohort, they are nothing more than types oft-repeated in different times and places. They are not wrong to be contemptuous of themselves. (Reviewed:) Grade: (B+) Tweet Websites:-WIKIPEDIA: Dorothy Thompson -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson American journalist and writer (Encyclopaedia Britannica) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson (Britannica Kids) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson (US Holocaust Memorial Museum, Americans and the Holocaust) -ENTRY: Thompson, Dorothy (1893–1961) (Encyclopedia.com) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson (New World Encyclopedia) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson (Spartacus Educational) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson - Nominee 1893 - 1961 (The Legacy Project) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson (Americans and the Holocaust, US Holocaust Museum) -ENTRY: Dorothy Thompson (1893-1961) (Eleanor Roosevelt Papers Project) -COLLECTION: Thompson, Dorothy (1894-1961) (Hamburgisches Welt-Wirtschafts-Archiv (HWWA)) -INDEX: Dorothy Thompson (Harper's) -COLLECTION: Dorothy Thompson Papers (An inventory of her papers at Syracuse University) -INDEX: Dorothy Thompson (Foreign Affairs) -INDEX: Dorothy Thompson (Jewish Telegraph Agency) -INDEX: Dorothy Brown Thompson (Unz.com) -INDEX: Dorothy Thompson (Harpers) -OBIT: Dorothy Thompson Dead at 66; Newspaper Colummst, Author; Foreign Affairs Specialist Had Wide Pre-War Influence--Ex-Wife of Sinclair Lewis (The New York Times, Feb. 1, 1961) -ESSAY: Who Goes Nazi? (Dorothy Thompson, August 1941, Harper's) -ESSAY: DOROTHY THOMPSON TELLS OF NAZI BAN: ; Believes She Was Expelled for 'Blasphemy' in Thinking Hitler an Ordinary Man. STRESSES WRITERS' PLIGHT Correspondent Who Seeks Facts Is Treated as Enemy, She Says -- Recalls Liberal Days. (Dorothy Thompson, Aug. 27, 1934, NY Times) -ESSAY: Do Israeli Ties Conflict with U.S. Citizenship?:America Demands a Single Loyalty: There exists a famous American document to which reference is often made, but which few people read. (Dorothy Thompson, March 1950, Commentary) -ESSAY: The Problem Child of Europe (Dorothy Thompson, April 1940, Foreign Affairs) -ESSAY: What Liberalism Means to Me (Dorothy Thompson, September 1947, The American Mercury) -ESSAY: Our Ghostly Commonwealth (Dorothy Thompson, Excerpted from the article originally published July 27, 1935, Saturday Evening Post) -ESSAY: Wilt Thou not Walk (Dorothy Thompson, Harpers) -VIDEO: Dorothy Thompson Interview - June 1941 (1941) (British Pathé) -QUOTES: 30 Best Dorothy Thompson Quotes (BooKey) -RADIO BROADCAST: 1939-09-03 NBC Dorothy Thompson Hitler Invasion of Poland (LibriVox) -RADIO BROADCAST: NBC Radio September 6, 1939 – Dorothy Thompson Has A Few Words About Current Events (Gordon Skene, September 6, 2019, Past Daily: A Sound Archive of News, History, Music) -PODCAST INDEX: Dorothy Thompson (Listen Notes) -PODCAST: Part 1: The Blue-Eyed Tornado: Hitler's Olympics (BBC Radio: Revisionist History, 6/28/24) -PODCAST: American Cassandra: The Life of Dorothy Thompson with Peter Kurth (Gaslit Nation, 12/27/23) -PODCAST: S7 Ep 7 - Dorothy Thompson (Chickstory, , April 17, 2024) -PODCAST: Journalists: Dorothy Thompson (Womanica, 2/25/21) -VIDEO:Susan Hertog, author, "Dangerous Ambition: Rebecca West and Dorothy Thompson (CUNY TV: One to One) -VIDEO: JSTOR Research: Dorothy Thompson (Richard Lucas, 9/3/21) -PODCAST: The Woman Who Interviewed Hitler (The LRB Podcast, , January 17, 2023) -PODCAST: It Can’t Happen Here: Part 1 – “I Saw Hitler” -023 (Mysteries, Myths & More, 4/16/24) -ESSAY: A Good Journalist Understands That Fascism Can Happen Anywhere, Anytime: On the 1930s Antifascist Writing of Dorothy Thompson (Nancy Cott, April 30, 2020. LitHub) -PODCAST: The Woman Who Interviewed Hitler (The LRB Podcast, Jan 17, 2023) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson, the Journalist Who Warned the World About Adolf Hitler: After this crusading reporter was kicked out of Germany, she continued her anti-Nazi coverage at home. (Kristin Hunt, Mental Floss) -ESSAY: Words of Warning: Dorothy Thompson's 1930's journalism still rings true (Peter Kurth, October 27, 2004, Seven Days) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson Expelled from Germany: August 26, 1934 (History Unfolded) -ESSAY: "Weizmann to her was God": Dorothy Thompson's Journey to and from Zionism1 (Walker Robins, January 2022, American Jewish History) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson Is the Most Famous Female Journalist You've Never Heard Of: She made a name for herself by speaking out against fascism abroad and at home. Then the fight got personal. (Kirstin Butler, 1/11/24, American Experience: Nazitown USA) -ESSAY: Early on, journalist Dorothy Thompson saw Hitler for what he was (Jonathan P. Baird, 08-15-2019, Concord Monitor) -ARTICLE: GERMANY: Little Man (TIME, September 3, 1934) -ESSAY: Misjudging Adolf Hitler (Alan Singer, Janice Chopyk, and Debra Willett, NJCS Journal) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson: Commentary and Analysis of the European Situation for NBC Radio (August 23-September 6, 1939): Added to the National Registry: 2023 (Nancy F. Cott, Library of Congress)[PDF] -THESIS: “a Mighty Woman With A Torch”: Dorothy Thompson Call For American Action Against Nazism And Jewish Persecution, 1931-1945 (Kiara Brynne Day, 2020, University of Vermont) [PDF] -ARTICLE: BOOK ON HITLER BANNED; Dorothy Thompson's Book, Published in 1932, Ridiculed Nazi (NY Times, Jan. 21, 1937) -ESSAY: Adolf Hitler, Dorothy Thompson, and Tucker Carlson’s Controversial Interview With Vladimir Putin: There’s been no shortage of American journalists who have conducted interviews with dictators, theocrats, and outright monsters (Jon Miltimore, 2/15/24, FEE) -ESSAY: An Interview with Hitler, August 17, 1932 (The Wisconsin Magazine of History) -ESSAY: Considering History: Dorothy Thompson Warned of Fascism in the U.S. and in Nazi Germany: Thrown out of Germany for writing about Hitler, journalist Dorothy Thompson went on to warn Americans about fascism in their own backyard. (Ben Railton, 10/10/2022, Saturday Evening Post) -ESSAY: Dorothy - I (Peter Kurth, May 09, 2024, Substack) -ESSAY: Dorothy - II (Peter Kurth. May 12, 2024, Substack) -ESSAY: WOMAN OF HER YEAR (Peter Kurth, May 1990, Vanity Fair) -INTERVIEW: Q&A: Karina von Tippelskirch on Journalist Dorothy Thompson (Cyndi Moritz, 3/21/18, Syracuse University) -THESIS: “a Mighty Woman With A Torch”: Dorothy Thompson's Call For American Action Against Nazism And Jewish Persecution, 1931-1945 (Kiara Brynne Day, 2020, UVM) -STUDY GUIDE: Truth in Journalism and Dorothy Thompson (greater Good in Education) -ESSAY: Breakfast With Dorothy Thompson (E. B. White, May 19, 1939, The New Yorker) -ESSAY: Adolf Hitler, Dorothy Thompson, and Tucker Carlson’s Controversial Interview With Vladimir Putin: There’s been no shortage of American journalists who have conducted interviews with dictators, theocrats, and outright monsters. (Jon Miltimore, February 15, 2024, FEE) -ESSAY: American Journalist Dorothy Thompson Underestimates Hitler: Adolf Hitler had shown little interest in talking to foreign reporters, but in late 1931, when he was widely seen as Germany's next leader, he finally agreed to meet with Dorothy Thompson, a savvy American reporter with a keen eye and a crisp style. (Peter Carlson8/6/2015, History Net) - -ESSAY:Early on, journalist Dorothy Thompson saw Hitler for what he was (Jonathan P. Baird, 08-15-2019, Concord Monitor) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson and Hitler (Linda Shenton Matchett, Heroes, Heroines & History) -ESSAY: Meet the First American Journalist to Interview Hitler—and the First Expelled From Nazi Germany: Dorothy Thompson deserves to be far better remembered than she presently is. (Lawrence W. Reed, January 29, 2023, FEE) -ESSAY: Sunday Pages: "Who Goes Nazi?": An essay by Dorothy Thompson. (Greg Olear, Nov 10, 2024, Prevail) -ESSAY: “What a Woman!” The Story of Dorothy Thompson and Sinclair Lewis: "What a Woman!" That's how reporter George Seldes responded when asked about Dorothy Thompson. (Jeff Nilsson, July 13, 2011, Saturday Evening Post) -ESSAY: Then Again: Barnard farm lured famous couple, but couldn’t bind them (Mark Bushnell, August 27, 2017, VT Digger) -ESSAY: Cartwheel Girl (TIME, June 12, 1939) -ARTICLE: HITLER POWER SEEN IN MIDDLE CLASS; Dorothy Thompson, Back From Germany, Calls Him 'Apothe- osis of the Little Man.' REVOLT AGAINST CULTURE' Aristocracy and Intellectuals Are Ignored In 'Fantastic' Nazi Revolution, Writer Finds. (NY Times, May 12, 1933) -ESSAY: The Journalist Who Stood Up to Hitler (Kylie Ora Lobell, August 15, 2023, Aish) -ARTICLE: Dorothy Thompson Describe Hitler Regime as 'Receivership of Broken Down Bourgeois Order' (Harvard Crimson, January 13, 1936) -ESSAY: Why Dorothy Thompson Lost Her Job: Political Columnists and the Press Wars of the 1930s and 1940s (Lynn D. Gordon, Autumn 1994, History of Education Quarterly) -ESSAY: Our Dictator: Dorothy Thompson on Fascism in America (1937) (Arash Narouzi, 11/07/20, The Mossadegh Project) -ESSAY: The Press: Without Regrets (TIME, February 10, 1961) -ESSAY: The journalist who stood up to Hitler Religion Zone (Kylie Ora Lobell, Aug. 27, 2023, Southern Eye) -ESSAY: Journalist Dorothy Thompson's Warnings About Fascism – Abroad and at Home (Ben Railton, 10/10/22, History News Network) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson: Precursor to Lane, Paterson and Rand?: Thompson’s blistering attacks on political and economic authoritarianism abroad mirrored what she often said about similar developments here in America (Lawrence W. Reed, 2/05/23, FEE) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson, In Search of The Fuhrer (Kathleen Sterling, May 10, 2020, Oz Wisdoms and Lessons) -ESSAY: Dorothy Thompson Describe Hitler Regime as 'Receivership of Broken Down Bourgeois Order' (Harvard Crimson, January 13, 1936) -ESSAY: She Saw Hitler II (Tom Clavin, Dec 30, 2021, The Overlook) - - - - - - -REVIEW: of I Saw Hitler. By Dorothy Thompson (J. W. Wheeler-Bennett, International Affairs) -REVIEW: of I Saw Hitler (William C. White, NY Times) -REVIEW: of -REVIEW: of The Courage to be Happy by Dorothy Thompson (Kirkus) -REVIEW: of -REVIEW: of LISTEN, HANS. By Dorothy Thompson (Carl J. Friedrich, The Atlantic) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra: The Life of Dorothy Thompson by Peter Kurth (Publishers Weekly) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (Herbert Mitgang, NY Times) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (Chris Goodrich, LA Times) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (Kenneth S. Lynn, Commentary) In the summer of 1900, just before her seventh birthday, a little girl stood in her parents’ house in Tonawanda, New York, and watched the approach of a killer cyclone. “Are we going to die?” she cried, and her father, a Methodist minister, replied as he always replied in crises, “We are in the hands of God.” Through all the vicissitudes of a cyclonic century, Dorothy Thompson was sustained by her father’s faith and uplifted by his example. As she declared in 1957, her political philosophy was grounded “in the Evangelium”—in “those precepts of respect for truth, mercy, forgiveness, humility, and charity, taught and admonished by Him whom I do not hesitate to call the Lord and Savior of my soul”—while her work as an opinion-maker was a secular form of preaching. “There is only one effective revolution,” she told the graduating class at Syracuse in 1937, “and that is the revolution represented by the evangelical idea of conversion: that men see where they have been wrong; that a light dawns upon them; and that they change their ways.” -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (Kirkus) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (Geoffrey C. Ward, NY Review of Books) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (Thomas Griffith, NY Times Book Review) -REVIEW: of American Cassandra (David Gates, Newsweek) "With a clang like a powerfully swung hammer," said another half-remembered Dorothy (Canfield Fisher), "she beat upon [the] general confusion of mind till the will to defend democracy was forged." -REVIEW: of FIGHTING WORDS: THE BOLD AMERICAN JOURNALISTS WHO BROUGHT THE WORLD HOME BETWEEN THE WARS by Nancy F. Cott (Kirkus) -REVIEW: of The Newspaper Axis: Six Press Barons Who Enabled Hitler by Kathryn Olmsted & Last Call at the Hotel Imperial: The Reporters Who Took on a World at War by Deborah Cohen. (Deborah Friedell, London Review of Books) -PLAY REVIEW: “Cassandra Speaks” (Gail Burns and Roseann Cane, Berkshire Onstage) Book-related and General Links: |
Copyright 1998-2015 Orrin Judd