BrothersJudd.com
Loading

Home | Reviews | Blog | Daily | Glossary | Orrin's Stuff | Email

Listen to a bestseller for $7.49 at audible.com!
Download and Listen to any Audiobook for only $7.49. Save 50% for 3 months on over 100,000 Titles.

The Roots of Heaven ()


Brothers Judd Top 100 of the 20th Century: Novels (21)

    [L]et's speak a little about symbols.  We may as well, as there has hardly been a critic who has not
    referred to The Roots of Heaven as a symbolic novel.  I can only state firmly and rather hopelessly
    that it is nothing of the sort.  It has been said that my elephants are really symbols of freedom, of
    African independence.  Or that they are the last individuals threatened with extinction in our
    collective, mechanized, totalitarian society.  Or that these almost mythical beasts evoke in this
    atheistical age an infinitely bigger and more powerful Presence.  Or, then again, that they are an
    allegory of mankind itself menaced with nuclear extinction.  There is almost no limit to what you
    can make an elephant stand for, but if the image of this lovable pachyderm thus becomes for each of
    us a sort of Rorschach test--which was exactly my intention--this does not make him in the least
    symbolic.  It only goes to prove that each of us carries in his soul and mind a different notion of
    what is essential to our survival, a different longing and a personal interpretation, in the largest
    sense, of what life preservation is about.
           -Romain Gary, Author's Introduction to the 1964 Time-Life Books version of The Roots of Heaven

It is one of the peculiarities of great literature, that having created it, the author sometimes loses control of it.  Thus, Don Quijote, the first and greatest novel of Western Literature, may have been intended by Cervantes to be a devastating parody of the chivalric tales, but instead of making us scoff at the Don's antiquated ideas, the book gave us the quintessential romantic idealist hero.  Similarly, when he wrote his Prix Goncourt winning book The Roots of Heaven, Romain Gary may have thought that he had crafted a novel of immense ambiguity, but readers have had little trouble finding in this tale of the French dentist Morel and his mad quest to save the elephants of Africa, a fairly straightforward metaphor for the struggle to preserve freedom.

Morel has come to a French Equatorial Africa which, in the wake of WWII, is percolating with unrest as the natives begin to agitate for independence.  Meanwhile, the European settlers who developed the territory wish to hold on to what they've created.  Added to the mix are various and sundry missionaries, anthropologists, prostitutes, traders, hunters, army deserters, and the like, who have all washed up in the colony.

Morel starts out by trying to get folks to sign a petition in favor of the elephants, but when he is met with scorn and indifference, he takes matters into his own hands and begins a campaign of low-grade (non-lethal) terrorism against those who hunt the animals.  He quickly becomes the most wanted man in the colony, and then a legendary figure to the whole world.  He is a hero to many, a traitorous and dangerous figure to the authorities, and a convenient opportunity to the rebels.  People, with widely varying motives, including fomenting revolution, begin to join his crusade.  At one point, when he is still petitioning, he explains to the local barmaid/prostitute, Minna, how he came to champion the elephant :

    I first began thinking about the elephants during the war, when I was a prisoner in Germany,
    probably because they were the most different thing I could imagine from what surrounded me :
    they were the very image of immense liberty.  Every time we looked at the barbed wire or were
    almost dying of misery and claustrophobia in solitary confinement, we tried to think of those big
    animals marching irresistibly through the open spaces of Africa, and it made us feel better.  Barely
    alive, starved, exhausted, we would clench our teeth and follow our great free herds obstinately with
    our eyes, and see them march across the savanna and over the hills, and we could almost hear the
    earth tremble under that living mass of freedom.  We tried not to speak of it, for fear the guards
    would notice, and sometimes we would just look at each other and wink, and then we knew that it
    was all right, that we could still see it, that it was still alive in us.  We held on to the image of that
    gigantic liberty, and somehow it helped us to survive.

So regardless of Gary's supposed intent, Morel's own words, here and throughout the book, would seem to indicate that he himself sees the elephants as symbol's of freedom.

It would have been easy enough for Gary to simply turn Morel into an unalloyed hero, a classic freedom fighter, but he does not.  Gary refers to Morel as an extremist of hope, and the emphasis is equally placed on the extremism.    A Jesuit priest in the novel, loosely modeled on Tielhard de Chardin, quite accurately indicts Morel for elevating the idea of the elephants above even his fellow man.  I think it's the priest who points out that Morel has chosen to place his hopes in the elephants because they are without sin, and the inability to accept Man's nature which this choice reflects is at heart anti-human.  In addition, Gary does not simply demonize those who oppose Morel; many of them are just as idealistic as he.  One of the best set speeches in the book comes from one of the colonists, whose elephant hunting wife Morel has just sentenced to a public flogging :

    I know the tune.  The elephants, you say.  But it's only Europeans who have hunting weapons and
    who can afford permits, and what you mean is that we are the only people who are exploiting and
    exhausting Africa's natural wealth.  That's a tune I've heard ever since I've been here, but the truth is
    that Africa's wealth isn't exploited enough, and that without us it wouldn't be exploited at all, and its
    very existence would be unknown.  Without us, the so-called 'colonists'--and I'm not ashamed of that
    name--not a single vein of ore would be discovered, and the population wouldn't have doubled in
    twenty years.  When I arrived here I found only syphilis, leprosy and sleeping sickness : I cured my
    people, fed them, clothed them, gave them work, houses and ambition--the desire to do what we do.
    It's men like me who have been, and still are, the leaven of Africa.  You and your lot call that
    'shameless exploitation of Africa's natural wealth'; I call it building up a new Africa for all, and first
    of all for the Africans.  But because ivory was the first thing we were after when we came here at
    the turn of the century and because we're the only ones to hunt with modern weapons, you've
    thought it smart to make elephant hunting the symbol of capitalist exploitation.

Now this assessment of Morel's motives is quite wrong, but it's important for a couple of reasons.  First, it presents a legitimate defense of the colonists.  Second, the very misunderstanding reflects the reason why, even though Morel is generally a sympathetic figure, the Europeans may be right to resist him, because even though his motives may be pure, others can warp them to their own ends.

One of the characters explains the title of the book this way :

    Our needs--for justice, for freedom and dignity--are roots of heaven that are deeply imbedded in
    our hearts, but of heaven itself men know nothing but the gripping roots...

The ferocity with which Morel clings to this sentiment and the absurd grandeur of his fight make him one of the more unforgettable heroes in all of literature and one whom it's odd to find in a French novel.  Then again, as another charcter says of him :

    I believe Morel was defending a certain idea of decency--the way we are treated on this earth filled
    him with indignation.  At bottom, he was an Englishman without knowing it.

The book is not currently in print and it's not easy to find, but it's well worth the effort.

(Reviewed:)

Grade: (A+)

  

Websites:

Romain Gary Links:

    -Romain Gary (1914-1980) - original surname Kacew, also wrote as Émile Ajar (kirjasto)
    -WIKIPEDIA: Romain Gary
    -FILMOGRAPHY: Romain Gary (IMDB)
    -PROFILE: Romain Gary: au revoir et merci: Romain Gary was the most glamorous of literary conmen. He wrote novels under many names, won major prizes and married an iconic actress. But in the end, writes David Bellos, his fictions destroyed him. (David Bellos, 12 Nov 2010, Telegraph)
    -PROFILE: Great Pretenders: In Romain Gary’s family, invention was the necessity of mother and son (Emma Garman, Oct 31, 2007, Tablet)
    -BOOK PAGE: Romain Gary: The Man Who Sold His Shadow by Ralph Schoolcraft (University of Pennsylvania Press)
    -GOOGLE BOOK: Romain Gary: the man who sold his shadow By Ralph W. Schoolcraft
    -PROFILE: Romain Gary: A Short Biography (Madeleine Schwartz, Harvard Advocate)
    -
   
-ESSAY: Romain Gary's The Dance of Genghis Cohn (commentary by rbadac)
    -ESSAY: Tirvengadum, "Linguistic Fingerprints and Literary Fraud"
    -PROFILE: The Furious Literary Prankster, Romain Gary (Benjamin Ivry, 9/20/10, The Arty Semite)
    -ARTICLE: Literary odd man out: THE Museum of Letters and Manuscripts in Paris recently paid a somewhat belated homage to one of the most popular but also enigmatic and controversial literary figures of our times. (Zafar Masud, April 14, 2011, Dawn)
    -ARTICLE: Romain Gary, Vilnius-born French Jewish novelist, honoured with statue (AFP, 6/24/07)
    -ESSAY: Congress, Torture and Romain Gary's 'Chien Blanc' (Benjamin Davis, December 2007, JURIST)
    -REVIEW: of A European Education by Romain Gary (TIME, 5/14/1960)
    -REVIEW: of Pseudo (Hocus Bogus) by Romain Gary (David Bellow, The Browser)
    -REVIEW: of Romain Gary’s “Hocus Bogus” (Morten Høi Jensen, Words without Borders)
    -REVIEW: of
   
-REVIEW: of
   
-REVIEW: of The Life Before Us (Madame Rosa) by Romain Gary (EuroWeekly)
    -REVIEW: of Romain Gary: A Tall Story, By David Bellos (David Coward , Independent)
    -REVIEW: of Romain Gary: A Tall Story (Patricia Duncker, Literary Review)
    -REVIEW: of Romain Gary: A Tall Story (STUART KELLY, The Scotsman)
    -REVIEW: of Tall Story (Josh Lacey, The Guardian)
    -REVIEW: of Tall Story (Stoddard Martin, Jewish Chronicle)
    -REVIEW: of Tall Story (Gilbert Adair, Spectator)

Book-related and General Links:
    -Romain Gary (1914-1980) - original surname Kacew, also wrote as Émile Ajar
    -ENCYCLOPÆDIA BRITANNICA : Gary, Romain
    -The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition.  2001. :  Gary, Romain
    -EXCERPT :  Excerpt from 'Roots of Heaven'
    -ARTICLE : GARY WON '75 GONCOURT UNDER PSEUDONYM 'AJAR'  (FRANK J. PRIAL, Special to the New York Times)
    -ESSAY : Tirvengadum, "Linguistic Fingerprints and Literary Fraud"
    -ESSAY : Romain Gary's The Dance of Genghis Cohn (commentary by rbadac)
    -REVIEW : of KING SOLOMON. By Romain Gary (Michiko Kakutani, NY Times)
    -REVIEW : of KING SOLOMON. By Romain Gary (John Weightman, NY Times Book Review)
    -REVIEW : of PLAYED OUT: The Jean Seberg Story. By David Richards (Mel Gussow, NY Times)
    -REVIEW : of PLAYED OUT The Jean Seberg Story. By David Richards (Janet Maslin, NY Times Book Review)
    -ENCYCLOPÆDIA BRITANNICA : Prix Goncourt

FILM :
    -FILMOGRAPHY : "Romain Gary" (Imdb)
    -FILM : The  Roots of Heaven (1958) (Imdb)

GENERAL :
    -ESSAY :  SUCCESS AND THE PSEUDONYMOUS WRITER: TURNING OVER A NEW SELF (Joyce Carol Oate, NY Times Book Review)
    -REVIEW : of Africa's Elephant: A Biography by Martin Meredith (John Preston, booksonline)

Comments:

Never seen the movie, though I've looked for it. Leonard Maltin refers to it as "turgid melodramatics".

- oj

- Oct-22-2002, 11:48

*******************************************************

I didn't know anyone out there remembered this wonderful novel-- never mind someone who shares my politcs! Now I'm going to have to look at ALL your novel recommendations.

Have you seen the movie based on it? I have, but about 30 years ago, so I can't remember how good it was. But it was by John Huston, perhaps the best director ever at adapting literature to film.

- Steve Bodio

- Oct-22-2002, 11:22

*******************************************************